This is an uncharacteristic post. I reserve the right to delete it. But here's my take on the whole question of my unsuccessful love life.
1) Thanks for the comments, and for your support.
2) I have heard the "men are intimidated" comment too many times to dismiss it out of hand. Where does this come from if there's no truth to it? Plus I know intelligent men who have confessed to being intimidated by strong women; to wanting a woman who is not challenging. I have heard smart, cool, men describing a mutual friend, and why she's attractive. "She's the least intimidating person I've ever met." There's something about putting people at ease that is a feminine characteristic. There's something about softness and sensitivity and openness that's attractive. I think part of that "you are strong and that scares men" statement is about this softness, the feminine ability to make a safe place where emotion and vulnerability are accepted.
I think I'm actually pretty soft and sensitive and open. You blog readers might see this more easily than others do. You see me walking around and looking at the beautiful things in the world, you see me crying when I hear a song full of heartbreak and yearning. You see all the things I notice and how I respond to the world with emotion. I'm intuitive and I'm learning to trust that side of myself. This is a place where I do that more and more.
I'm not sure this is what the world sees. I don't have conversations where I say, "the moon this morning hung still in the sky and the air was so cold that smoke was rising off the water and the way the ducks hunched together in small groups made me long for the warmth of my kitchen," or those kind of snippets that I put down here regularly. In life, I tend to be saying things like, "Let's go have a drink and play cheesy bar games!" That's a caricature, perhaps, but not so much of one. I am a social organizer and I'm tuned into other people's comfort zones and I entertain and schmooze and sparkle and listen and laugh and in all these ways I'm Rock Star Charisma Barbie. And in professional situations I'm busy asking all kinds of questions and solving problems and making connections and being logical and rational and competitive and curious and engaged. Those two personas are me, they're real. But they're not a complete picture of me. You guys don't see them so much. The rest of the world sees them 95% of the time.
3) It is my habit to hide the sad, lonely, and vulnerable parts of myself. It is true that I am pretty confident, fairly capable, reasonably smart. I'm generally optimistic and cheerful, absorbed and contented with my life. I think it's fair to say that my baseline mood is a pretty high level of happiness. So if people think I'm happy and complete, well, they're mostly right. But the things that worry me and fill me with dread and shame, the places in my emotional life where I feel clumsy and broken and half-formed, the things I'm struggling with, the things I yearn for that I don't know how to find for myself, the places that scare me, the ways I haven't yet learned to be comfortable, the part of me that just wants to be held, well, all that stuff I do not share easily. My own neediness scares me, and because of that I think it will scare others. So I keep it to myself. And what comes across about me is a picture of a happy girl, and all the ways I'm confident and sure of myself and engaged with the world. Those parts are true. But there is more about me than that. I'm a girl who's lonely at times, who feels stunted and broken in ways, who wants encouragement and comfort but doesn't know how to ask for it.
It's why I don't understand how on earth I could seem intimidating. I don't feel intimidating. But I think I might be, in some ways. And the ways I might seem intimidating aren't necessarily ones that make it the man's fault for not responding to me. It's not so much that I think what I project is validly intimidating. But I think there may be men looking for a softness, who don't see it in me even though it is there, and who turn away and look elsewhere.
4) I think my project is to become braver about those ways I don't have things together, rather than trying to barricade them off and project only my strengths. I don't think that's about "catching a man," but rather a larger project, about being more honest and complete in my life. Letting go of the fear of my own unresolved parts. I was worrying about something the other day and thinking that I could use some good advice. And I realized that I never, ever, ever ask for advice about things that really worry me. If you're a friend you might think I am asking you for advice but by the time I get to a place where I can make something public I've usually worked out my own answer and am coming to you for confirmation or a reality check. Unless I'm crying when I talk to you it's probably not raw, or fresh. It's already been worked through. It takes years and years of knowing me before I will cry in front of you. I cry alone.
5) It's true that I don't want a man who would want me "dumbed down." Or who would be threatened by my success or my confidence. ("Success" being entirely theoretical, since I don't know quite what it means, or whether it's in store for me.) I don't want a man who's afraid to ask me out. I want to feel loved and wanted and worth pursuing, like a special prize. All of that suggests that I should wait to be asked out, and then sort from the pool of men who've done that. (And it comports with all of the bestselling pink-covered dating advice books in Barnes & Noble.) But I ask out men from time to time, and I like that about myself. I like being the kind of person who reaches out and who takes emotional risks, who follows my intuition. In every other aspect of my life -- professionally, socially, creatively -- when I reach out to someone and try to make a connection I am rewarded with warmth and gratitude. I believe in reaching out. Except that it means that by doing that I am, by definition, investing some hope in people who haven't already decided I'm worth pursuing. It makes me feel like I'm auditioning, in an arena I feel I've already failed at again and again. It's scary, and it makes me doubly likely to cover up those broken, soft, vulnerable parts, and turn on my high beam personality, dazzle with smarts and confidence and charm.
6) The solution, I guess, is the same. Just try to be braver. Reach out when I feel a connection. Respond when someone reaches out to me. Be myself. All of myself. Which means the broken parts and the sad parts and the soft parts and the little lost girl parts as well as the grown up capable friendly together parts.