I've been listening to The Old Ceremony, a band headed by my college classmate Django Haskins. I didn't know Django as an undergraduate, but talked to him a bit at my reunion. He struck me as smart, and interesting, and so I had pretty high expectations of the CD.
It's very good. I've been thinking about how to describe it and wishing I had a vocabulary for talking about music that is much better than what I actually have. It's swingy and lounge-y music, making good use of a whole lot of instruments -- horns, fiddle, piano, accordion . It's cool, both in the generic "I approve of this" sense and in the "cool as a cucumber" sense. On their website I see the adjectives "pop noir" and "cabaret" and "chamber pop" used by various reviewers to describe their sound. Those aren't terribly evocative to me, but maybe they are to you. "Moody" and "eclectic" and "a card-shark's finesse" are even better.
The 'card shark's finesse' captures the kind of cool I am struck by the most. It's the smooth perfection of an Ocean's 11 heist. Supertight musicians who are worldly and unruffled. Although the music doesn't have the same sound, there's something about this that reminds me of Steely Dan: a kind of dispassionate skill, a precision crafting of complex and interesting songs. Any emotion is tightly contained. Lyrics have a detached edge to them. Soundwise, the songs are more closely related to Andrew Bird's Bowl of Fire, or perhaps Neko Case, than to anything else in my library.
And I like the CD very much. I keep getting the tunes stuck in my head, keep changing my mind about which one I like best, keep noticing new things to like in each song. But the composure and the precision cause me to keep a little something back from my admiration. I realize that I respond to a ragged edge in music, a touch of looseness, maybe even the slightest bit of unraveling. The catch in the singer's voice, a blurring around the edges of the notes, a hint of recklessness. I'd give up a little bit in the musical perfection department to get a little bit more of something -- vulnerability, maybe? That's not what these guys are about. The comparison to Ocean's Eleven feels good. It's about precision, and keeping cool.
In any event, I still rate the CD a strong buy. You can download some of the songs at the band's website to give them a try....