This Fish posted recently about a failed relationship. One of the problems, she notes, was a blog post about a previous relationship that the fellow she was dating didn't like. She is angry at him, it is clear, and her post is not kind. The disputed post isn't kind, either. There's a bee sting in both of the posts, the narrator rubbing a red welt and lashing out at the men who inflicted it. In each post, she tells someone else's secrets, in a voice of contempt. It makes me sad. I like This Fish for her honesty, but I also like her because I sense that she is kind. Posts like these, with the attendant dozens of "you go, girl!" comments from loyal readers who relish the snarky deconstruction, make me feel betrayed in that belief. These stories are hers to tell, I suppose, but they also hold the secrets of men whose lives she touched. Even if the men aren't worthy romantic partners, they are people, not anecdotes, and if she cared enough about them to feel stung and disappointed, they deserve better than caricature. I hate that people seem to like contempt so much.
I blog from time to time about my own romantic life. Mostly, I don't. That's for a lot of reasons. The most obvious one is that my romantic life is in flux, and has been for most of the life of this blog. I'm afraid to count on it when things are good, and I'm afraid to tell the truth and expose my vulnerability when things are bad. I'm afraid to write about it because my words, out there in public, might affect my real-world life. I'm afraid to acknowlege my longing, give power to my fears, own up to my confusion. I'm afraid to clutch too tightly to happiness. I haven't managed to hold on to it yet.
The alternative is this strange coy silence, as if I'm not all those things: confused, longing, vulnerable, happy, afraid. I am all of them, sometimes all at once, sometimes in quick succession, and sometimes one at a time, flooded and overwhelmed. I haven't learned how to write about it.
Do you know anyone who does, without sounding hardened, or stung, or contemptuous? I'd like to read that kind of writing: honest, from someone with an open heart.