This morning as I was merging on the highway the guy in the blue and white Suburban coming in from my right was holding a cup of coffee, and I felt a pang of envy. I still miss coffee. As I drove, I considered trying to start back up drinking it again. I occasionally drink iced coffee without ill effects. And I ordered a soy latte a few months back and actually forgot that a latte has espresso in it, so I was surprised by what I got. But it wasn't unpleasant.
Why not start drinking coffee again? It makes me feel bad -- that's why I haven't started up since I quit in 1997 or 1998. Not in a moral or ethical sense, but physically. I get a physical sensation of toxicity, dirtiness, when I swallow coffee. There's a recoiling, a feeling that I'm harming my body, that makes it hard to drink more than a couple of sips. Trust me, I'm no temple of health -- I'll happily drink gin or whiskey, or eat the french fries off your plate. And I drink at least 6 cups of tea a day, usually with caffeine. This isn't conscientiousness. It's something physical about coffee that happened after I quit.
But as I checked the rearview mirror and saw the guy in the Suburban -- middle aged, baseball cap, overweight -- holding that white cup in his left hand, I held a jealous grudge and started to scheme about overcoming my physical coffee aversion. I'm sure I could reacclimate myself to drinking coffee again. I could introduce it slowly, in small doses, gradually increasing to a full cup. Mmmm, a full cup. Oh, it's been so long time since I had that pleasure. I used to take it with a little cream. I loved to pour the cream in and not stir it, just watch the white liquid dispersing itself in irregular but intricate patterns into the dark brown. I liked watching it and smelling it and waiting until it was ready to drink. I'd drink it with cream if I started up again. Or maybe I'd drink it black....
Why would I do that? Coffee's not good for you. It's addictive. It stains your teeth and gives you bad breath and makes you jumpy, and you get a headache if you have too much or too little. Besides the caffeine, there are all kinds of toxic molecules in the beans, and loads of those are sprayed with some pretty gnarly pesticides. Back in college I took an environmental studies class from a professor who was very seriously studying pesticides and food toxicity, and I remember one of the readings about coffee. I highlighted a paragraph summarizing the bad stuff in coffee (not including caffeine) and hung it over my coffeemaker, which scared me off the stuff for a couple of weeks. In college, that was a big deal. I used to drink it by the pot. Even organic coffee doesn't solve it, if my memory is right. Some of the compounds within coffee are pretty bad for you. Of course I can't confirm or deny this hunch on the web, but the memory is strong. Was it formaldehyde that's a by-product of roasting? I came away convinced that coffee is a pretty serious toxin.
Anyway, why would I knowingly go back to a substance that was addictive to me and that makes my body feel bad now? Oh, because. Because coffee picks you up like nothing else does. Because coffee is inexpensive and can make you feel good in almost any situation. Because not drinking coffee makes me seem prissy and high-maintenance. It's the last acceptable vice; forswearing it makes me feel humorless and holier-than-thou, like a vegan. Because drinking coffee makes me part of a universal brotherhood of people who understand one another. Tea does not have the same number or fervency of adherents. It's a lonely beverage. In fact, I still suggest meeting someone "for coffee" now, rather than for a cup of tea, even though that is what I will invariably order. Having tea is too wimpy and upper crust. There's something good and hearty to a cup of coffee that's nice to share. It's a shared vice, a secret treat, a drug. Mmmmm.
And then I read a paragraph like that and I think, if I heard a cigarette smoker speaking that reverently about nicotine I would have no doubt it was the ravings of an addict. I've gotten off coffee. Why would I take it up again?